Independent and impartial Design Review

Independent Design Review

Design review is an independent and impartial peer review system working across the North West of England as part of the Design Network, promoting the highest quality of design and placemaking throughout the region.

Utilising a multi-disciplinary panel of experts, Place Matter positively assists design teams in achieving high quality outcomes and supports Local Planning Authorities in determining the design quality of proposals.

To arrange a Design Review or to request more information please contact Richard Tracey.

07841 458 696

Richard.Tracey@placesmatter.co.uk

Design North West Panel

We seek to ensure that panel members skills are matched to the requirements of the projects under review and each panel will usually contain a mix of architects, landscape architects and urban designers, with planners, master planners, engineers, developers, historic and conservation specialists, and sustainability experts added when we feel this is needed.

Our current Advisory Board co-Chairs are Annie Coombs and Matt Brook.

Panel Chairs

  • I am co-Chair of the Places Matter and Chair of its Advisory Board. 

    I’m a Design Council Ambassador where I chair design panels.  I was one of two deputy chairs of the HS2 independent design panel and I remain a panel member.  I sat on CABE’s national design panel and I was a CABE enabler, writing the landscape briefs for the Olympic, Queen Elizabeth Park and the canoe slalom course for the Olympic Development Agency.

    I’m a landscape architect, with a master’s degree in planning.  I am an appointable person as Examining Inspector for the Planning Inspectorate for nationally significant infrastructure projects.  Previously I was a Commissioner of the Infrastructure Planning Commission.

    My career started in the public sector in Liverpool and London.  Then I worked in the private sector in Asia for 16 years.  My main Hong Kong project work was for large scale infrastructure, multi-disciplinary design teams.  I was managing director for offices in Hong Kong, Singapore and Kuala Lumpur.  

    I wrote the community engagement chapter in the ‘Handbook on Green Infrastructure’.  I’ve been active in community planning and volunteer on policy matters for the Landscape Institute.

  • I am the founder and leader of Matt BrookArchitects, an award-winning practice based in Manchester with a range of projects across the UK. My placemaking-led and people-focused approach underpins all of the work undertaken by the practice and informs the development of projects at all stages.

    Recent projects include the award-winning Phoenix Works in Manchester, Sauchiehall Street in Glasgow - a sensitive and prominent site within a city centre conservation area - and at Regent Park, where my masterplan will deliver a new park for Salford as part of a transformational regeneration of a strategically important site at a key gateway with Manchester City Centre.

    I have been a long-time advocate for the positive impact that great design can have on people and place, acting as current co-Chair of PlacesMatter, the independent Design Review Panel for the North-West. I’m a past Chair of the RIBA North-West region and have served on the RIBA National Council andwas a previous owner director and global head of design at the international practice Broadway Malyan.

    The rigorous approach that underpins my work demonstrates my commitment to people-focused, placemaking-led design and has resulted in a diverse portfolio of award-winning projects. This portfolio includes Mann Island, a RIBA Award-winning project that I designed and delivered at a highly significant and complex site on Liverpool’s Waterfront. Historic England highlighted the design of Mann Island as an exemplar response to this unique context of Listed Buildings. I went on to design and deliver RIBA North within the Mann Island complex; RIBA’s national architecture centre containing its largest museum-standard Gallery, providing an award-winning visitor experience for guests as a visitor hub for the historic waterfront.

  • As Associate Director in Urban Design, I lead the Northwest Place Team at SLR Consulting, drawing on 20+ years of experience across architecture, urban design, and landscape practices.

    My background includes leading major regeneration projects and masterplans across the UK. I specialise in shaping masterplans for complex and challenging sites, such as the Northern Gateway masterplan (PfE), former Jackson’s Brickworks masterplan and New Eastern Villages near Swindon. I sensitively integrate heritage assets within masterplans, including the historic Woolwich Royal Artillery Barracks in Greenwich and Green Walk, Standish.

    I’ve authored frameworks and guidance, notably Sheffield City Centre Priority Framework, Residential Capacity Studies for Sheffield and Leicester, Northwich Development Framework, Ashton Public Realm Strategy, Radcliffe SRF and Warrington Growth Ambition, collaborating with partners, bringing together diverse voices and disciplines. I’ve delivered several design codes and supported Design Code Training for local authorities.

    I’m committed to inclusive design and implement engagement with diverse stakeholder groups, ensuring all voices genuinely shape places. My passion lies in creating healthy, sustainable places with a strong sense of identity, memorable and people-focused places, rooted in their context. My goal is to raise design quality and create places that make everyday life better.

  • I am a specialist urban design and historic environment advisor and practitioner working in the urban design, masterplanning, planning, conservation and regeneration sectors since 1979.

    I co-founded Plus Urban Design Ltd in 2011 having previously been Urban Design Director at Space Group and Ryder Architecture; and Urban Design & Conservation Group Manager at Newcastle City Council.

    I am also Co-Chair of both the affiliated Designe North East and Design Yorkshire Design Review & Enabling Services; and a Design Network Building for a Healthy Life Evaluator.

    I am an Academician at the Academy of Urbanism; a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts and a Trustee of the Tyne & Wear Building Preservation Trust.

    I was previously a CABE panellist; Design Council BEE; and past Chair of the national Historic Towns & Villages Forum.

    I have had a career long commitment and expertise in local placemaking and creating healthy neighbourhoods working with local communities notably in Byker & the Ouseburn Valley in Newcastle; Worsley, Salford; and in Central Northampton.

    I am also an urban design and BfHL trainer at events run by Design Network partners including Places Matter.

  • I am a Director at Levitt Bernstein, passionate about creating high quality, inspirational places where people can thrive while building a sustainable legacy for future generations. I am particularly excited by the reimagining and transformative potential of thought-provoking sites that hold untapped opportunity.

    My 25+ years of experience has garnered expertise across the education, residential, and arts sectors and has taught me that the most rewarding architecture often emerges from embracing complex challenges and finding ways to turn constraints into catalysts for exceptional design.

    Since establishing and leading our Manchester Studio in 2013, I have wherever possible, advocated the innovative reuse of buildings and deep retrofit measures, seeing them as both an environmental obligation and a source of creative opportunity. I especially enjoy the process of unlocking the potential within heritage buildings and settings, working through the technical and logistical challenges of adaptation to meet contemporary needs, while honouring their inherent character and history.

    This appreciation was first informed during my early career working on Manchester's Royal Exchange Theatre following the 1996 bomb damage. Being part of the core team on that two-year refurbishment project enforced how inspired reuse can create something truly special and that the most perplexing sites often hold the greatest potential.

    My role on the Places Matter review panel since 2017 allows me to advocate for design excellence that, from macro-scale masterplanning to bespoke transformations, always puts people and place at its heart.

  • I am a founding director of Manchester based design practice MBLA Architects + Urbanists (formerly Mills Beaumont Leavey) and former director at Buttress Architects. I combined private practice with 15 years as a visiting tutor and assessor at the Manchester School of Architecture and an examiner in professional practice at The Bartlett, London and RIBA N.W.

    I am a past president of The Manchester Society of Architects and recipient of the 2017 Lifetime Achievement Award for significant contribution to architecture.

    I am an assessor for Building for a Healthy Life with over 15 years as a member of Places Matter design review panel, most recently as supporting chair and a member of the Advisory Board.

    I have enjoyed involvement in all project sectors with particular specialism in residential, regeneration and masterplanning. Highlighted projects include Sir William Siemens House, Homes for Change, Unity Theatre, Woods End, Design House, Icon 25, Atelier and Timekeepers Square. Selected masterplanning projects include Hulme regeneration, New Broughton, Collyhurst, Smithfield and Ancoats /New Islington.

    I have valued creative collaboration in all my work, enjoying the success of multiple awards and references in published works on design excellence.

  • I lead an independent design practice based in the NW and have approaching 30 years’ experience working within the landscape profession across the UK, sector areas and client groups having worked for Capita (London) LDA Design (Oxford) and Camlin Lonsdale (Huddersfield) prior to it rebranding to XQLA in 2018. 

    As a chartered landscape architect with a joint degree in plant science my capability has evolved through involvement in a broad range of challenging schemes ‘end to end’. This includes regional level green infrastructure projects, regeneration strategies, landscape character assessments and public realm design guides as well as area based visioning and landscape-led masterplanning.  Notable built projects include Holland House South Terrace & Café, London, Market Square, Stafford and Eton Olympic Rowing Lake.

    I relish collaborative working in the interest of raising awareness of the power of good landscape design to transform people’s everyday lives as well as enabling sustainable futures. Consequently, I also sit on the North East and Yorkshire Design Review Panels.  At a national level I have sat on the HS2 independent design panel since 2018 (deputy chair for three years) and have recently been appointed to provide landscape advice for Historic England’s Historic Places Panel. I am also a regular judge for the AJ Awards and a board member of Lancaster Arts.

Panel Managers

  • I am an independent regeneration and partnerships practitioner. I originally trained in Birmingham as a Town Planner, although I have now been in full recovery for the past 35 years. After a brief exile in Peterborough, I returned North for a dozen years to manage development projects, town centres and the countryside of Salford.

    This was followed by six-years heading up SRB partnerships on the Wirral and in Knowsley, championing the role of local communities, although they thought I just worked for the Council. 

    During almost a decade at the Northwest Regional Development Agency I established ‘RENEW’ - the North West Centre of Excellence for Regeneration; worked with the Forestry Commission to create 900ha of public green spaces; oversaw the funding for the revival of the Liverpool Garden Festival public realm; was a Board member of the Mersey Waterfront Regional Park; and, a jury member for a number of RIBA international architecture competitions, most notably, Adam Khan’s floating village at Brockholes, Preston.

    Before starting my own company, I spent three years at Liverpool Vision supporting the Everton Park Partnership in North Liverpool, after which I became Interim Project Director for the Atlantic Gateway Parklands. I have spent most of the last nine years running Places Matter, for which I have now completed over 400 Design Reviews.

    I try to find ways to understand the world using pictures and music, and list my hobbies as walking far too many marathons, helping to look after my five grandchildren and drinking three shot Grande Latte. 

  • Iain is director of IMT Consulting, a business he started in 2016 to advise clients on a range of subjects relating to the financing and implementation of development projects, natural capital and major economic partnership programmes.

    Iain is currently supporting St Helens Council on the development of a new medical glass manufacturing facility, purchase and re-development of a key life science focused development site and the master planning and delivery of a major 30 acre town centre brownfield site.

    As a Senior Associate of AMION Consulting, Iain is lead consultant on the successful LCR Freeport, LCR Life Science Investment Zone, Flintshire and Wrexham Investment Zone and the Enhanced Investment Zone in Northern Ireland.

    Iain has held a number of senior roles prior to his time in consultancy.  He was the executive director of Atlantic Gateway and director of business development for the Land Trust.  Prior to joining the Land Trust, Iain was partnerships director for the Peel Group.  Iain was part of the team that prepared the Atlantic Gateway concept and worked to promote collaboration between public sector partners on key strategic initiatives.

    Iain has supported the development of several major projects, including Glass Futures, MediaCityUK, Liverpool2 Container Port, Port Salford, City of Salford Stadium and several major road schemes and strategic green infrastructure projects.

    Iain has been engaged in infrastructure and property development as well as environmental project development and in air, water and land sectors in the UK and USA.

    Iain has a Post Graduate Certificate in Cross Sector Partnerships from the University of Cambridge and an honours degree in Economics and Geography from the University of Keele.  Iain is the chair of the Rossendale Towns Fund Board and Whitaker Museum and Art Gallery and director of Rossendale Leisure Trust.  He loves riding motorcyles, sailing boats and taking time out with his wife and two children.

Panel Members

A group of people gathered around a wooden table outdoors, looking at maps and documents, with some writing and discussing. The setting appears to be a garden or patio, with a wall decorated with bicycle wheels, a 'No Smoking' sign, and gardening plants in the background.
  • Description text goes here

Standard Fees

All fees are payable in advance. All other services quoted on request.

  • Design Review of single dwelling subject to Paragraph 80 of the NPPF

    £3,950 + VAT

  • Projects with more than one building or smaller residential schemes up to 150 dwellings:

    £3,950 + VAT

  • Larger residential schemes over 150 dwellings / sustainable urban expansion / garden village / major regeneration schemes:

    £4,950 + VAT

  • Desk Review of a previously seen scheme:

    charged at 50% of the original fee + VAT